Tuesday - Sunday 12pm-9pm | Closed Monday

Southwest Michigan's Best Ice Cream

About Us

Our Story

In 1978, Art and Judy Gaylord bought the building that formerly housed Newman’s Ice Cream. The rest is history.

Our Story  
Our Flavors

Plainwell Ice Cream serves dozens of amazing, original flavors for all palettes and delights.

Our Flavors  
Contact Us

Have a question? Would you like to become a distributor or buy in bulk for an event? Reach out, we'd love to help!

Contact Us  
  •   Distribution


    We love to work with distributors so that Plainwell Ice Cream can delight even more ice cream lovers in Southwest Michigan.

  •   Events


    Have a wedding, corporate event, graduation party, birthday, etc...? Get in touch, we'd love to provide you with ice cream.

  •   Contact Us


    Plainwell Ice Cream is online, on Facebook, and reachable by phone. Don't hesitate to reach out. We love hearing from customers.

Contact Us


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.