Call: (269) 685-8586

Hours: Mon - Sat: 11am - 9pm Sunday: 12pm - 9pm

FAQ

  • Do you ship your ice cream?
    – No, unfortunately we do not.
  • I’m interested in buying your ice cream for wholesale. Who should I contact?
    – Please contact Dave Gaylord or Art Gaylord. They can be reached here (sales@plainwellicecreamco.com) or by calling the ice cream store at (269) 685-8586.
  • What forms of payment do you accept?
    We accept cash, checks, Mastercard, Visa and Discover. We do not accept American Express.
  • Do you make all your ice cream?
    – Yes with the exception of the No Sugar Added ice cream and the Non dairy Sorbet.
  • Do you have any ice cream for people with dietary restrictions?
    – We try to have two flavors of No Sugar Added ice cream at all times. Usually butter pecan and cherry vanilla. We also try to have 1 non dairy sorbet. It is also vegan.
  • Does sherbet contain milk?
    Yes. Sherbet contains milk. Sorbet does not.
  • Can I order large quantities of ice cream for a special event?
    – Yes. Please call us at (269) 685-8586 or email us at (sales@plainwellicecreamco.com). We will be happy to help.
  • Can I get 2 flavors in a cone?
    – Yes! We are happy to put two flavors in either a small or large cone (or dish). No more please!
  • Do you make ice cream cakes?
    – No.
  • Do you have soft serve ice cream?
    – No.
  • Do you sell yogurt?
    – No.